Tuesday, January 6, 2026

Governor Hutchinson: The Proclamation Boston Wouldn’t Let Stand

Governor Thomas Hutchinson enters Broadside as a Massachusetts-born Loyalist who genuinely believes he’s preventing catastrophe. He’s not chasing cruelty, he’s chasing containment: keep Boston from tipping from argument into riot, from satire into blood. He thinks of himself as the adult in the room, the one responsible for consequences nobody else wants to name.

Several printers refused to publish Governor Hutchinson's Thanksgiving Day broadside
Edes & Gill refuse to publish Governor Hutchinson's broadside

His primary instrument isn’t a sword; it’s official paper. A proclamation broadside, read aloud and posted publicly, is how he tries to make reality hold still: disperse, obey, return to order. Play him as someone who treats the document with ceremony, measured voice and controlled posture because he believes law is the only thing separating “society” from “mob.”

Wheat pasting The Governor proclamation broadside
The Governor finds a printer and admires his proclamation broadside

Then the city answers back. His proclamations get mocked, sung over, and turned into fuel for the Patriot print machine; counter-broadsides, tavern choruses, laughter where he expects obedience. That’s where “us and them” is born for him: not as an idea, but as a feeling he looks up and realizes the crowd no longer sees a governor; they see an enemy.

The Three Drunken Maidens vandalizing Governor Hutchinson's Thanksgiving day broadside.
The Three Drunken Maidens vandalize the Governor's broadside after their performance.

His arc tightens from calm authority to brittle enforcement. The tragedy is that his fear of chaos makes him reach for harsher control, which only proves the Patriots’ point and deepens the split. For an audition: play the public face as composed, even polite, then let one private crack show the man underneath: wounded, cornered, and terrified of what happens if his words stop working.

Before the Bayonets, There Were Ballrooms: Margaret Gage Before the Intolerables

In the mid 1760s, the Gages weren’t “Boston people” yet, they were New York people. After Thomas Gage’s promotion, he and Margaret Kemble...